Faga; Lutu v.

Series: 1ASR | Year: 1933 | 1ASR480
Print This

LUTU of Utu1ei, Plaintiff


FAGA of Fagatogo, Dfendant

No. 3-1933

High Court of American Samoa
Civil Jurisdiction, Trial Division

 [Land: “Fauloloa” or “Paia” in Fagatogo]

February 6, 1933


Action to determine title to land “Fauloloa” or “Paia” in Fagatogo. High Court, Chief Justice H. P. Wood, presiding, held that plaintiff, as matai of the Lutu Famjly, was entitled to the land by adverse possession.

Judgment for plaintiff.

Adverse Possession-Possession-Through Agent or Tenant

Where lessee occupies property through written and recorded lease, such occupation shall constitute actual, visible, exclusive and hostile possession by lessor against other claimants to property.


H. P. WOOD, Chief Justice; MULI, Associate Judge


This case came on to be heard at a session of the High Court on Monday February 6th, 1933 before Chief Justice H. P. Wood and Associate Judge Muli.

Faagata of Fagatogo filed the land Fauloloa for registration and Lutu of Utulei objected. The law [1ASR481] Fauloloa is the site of the old L.M.S. Church in Fagatogo and where it is proposed to erect the new church.

Even assuming that the small piece of land in Fagatogo upon which the L.M.S. Church has stood for over 25 years was not included in the gift of the land which Faagata admits his Predecessor in title made to a Lutu many years ago, yet the facts remain that Lutu was granted land adjoining the land in question, both to the north and south and that Faagata during the period of 25 years never asserted any rights to this land.

Under these circumstances the Court must hold that the use and occupation of this land by the L.M.S. as lessee, under a written lease from Lutu made in 1904, and recorded in the office of the Registrar of Deeds of American Samoa in 1905, was such an actual, visible, exclusive and hostile possession by Lutu as to vest the title in him by adverse possession as the matai of the Lutu family. The land is called by Lutu, Paia.

Judgment is for Lutu as matai of the Lutu family. The costs amounting to $25.00 will be paid by Faagata.